mouth-watering reese’s peanut butter cup cheesecake recipe

Sharing is caring!

You Had Me at Peanut Butter Cup

Let me tell you about the time I brought this cheesecake to a potluck. My friend John – who claims to “not really like sweets” – ate three slices and then asked to take the leftovers home. That’s the magic of combining creamy peanut butter, rich chocolate, and that irresistible Reese’s crunch. This dessert? It’s not just a recipe. It’s a love letter to that iconic candy aisle flavor combination we’ve all snuck into movie theaters.

Now I know what you’re thinking: “But cheesecake is complicated!” Listen, I once cracked three eggs directly into a bowl of unmelted chocolate trying to improvise. This recipe? Foolproof. The crust bakes just enough to hold its shape, the filling comes together in one bowl, and the topping? Well, let’s just say if you mess up sprinkling peanut butter cups, you’re probably having too much fun.

What You’ll Need

For the Crust:

• 18 whole graham crackers (about 2 cups crushed)
• 1/2 cup melted butter
• 3 tablespoons sugar
• Pinch of salt (trust me on this)

For the Filling:

• 24 oz cream cheese (room temp! I leave mine out overnight)
• 1 cup granulated sugar
• 1 tbsp vanilla extract
• 1 1/2 cups chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups (about 15 regular size)
• 1 cup heavy cream

For That Showstopper Top:

• 1 cup Reese’s Pieces
• 1/4 cup melted chocolate chips
• Extra peanut butter cups for garnish

Building Your Masterpiece

1. The Crust That Won’t Crumble (On You):
   1. Preheat oven to 350°F. Throw graham crackers in a ziplock and crush with a rolling pin – great stress relief!
   2. Mix crumbs with melted butter and sugar. Press into 9″ springform pan like you’re sculpting a sandcastle. Bake 10 minutes. Let cool while you…
2. The Filling That Makes You Sneak Spoonfuls:
   1. Beat cream cheese until smooth (2 mins). If there’s lumps, your cheese was too cold – no biggie, just keep mixing.
   2. Add sugar and vanilla. Whip until fluffy. Toss in chopped Reese’s – reserve some for later!
   3. In separate bowl, whip cream to stiff peaks. Fold gently into cheese mixture. This is where overmixing happens – stop when you still see streaks.
3. Assembly Line of Deliciousness:
   1. Pour filling over cooled crust. Tap pan hard on counter 3 times – releases air bubbles you didn’t know existed.
   2. Chill 4 hours minimum. Overnight’s better. Yes, the wait’s brutal. Distract yourself with leftover Reese’s.

Pro Tips From My Kitchen Disasters

That time I used frozen peanut butter cups? Big mistake. They bleed color into the filling. Stick to room temp candies. And if your crust sticks to the pan (happened my first try), run a butter knife under hot water, dry it, then slide around edges.

Key Timesavers:

• Prep crust during baby naps/work calls
• Use pre-crushed graham crackers (nobody’s judging)
• Freeze leftovers in slices – they thaw perfectly

FAQs From Real Kitchen Warriors

“Can I make this gluten-free?”

Absolutely! Swap grahams for gluten-free Oreos. Made it for my celiac sister-in-law last Thanksgiving – she didn’t believe it was safe to eat.

“Help! My filling won’t set!”

Been there. Two culprits: undermixed cream (needs stiff peaks) or rushed chilling. If desperate, pop it in the freezer 90 minutes. Save the drama with a stabilized whipped cream next time.

“Can I use natural peanut butter?”

Oh honey, no. The texture’s all wrong. Stick to Reese’s magic ratio of sweet and salty. Your artisanal PB can wait for toast.

“How do I get clean slices?”

Run your knife under hot water between cuts. Learned this after serving a “rustic” (read: crumbled) slice to my mother-in-law. She still brings it up.